My husband and I went to Nick & Sam's for the first time to celebrate my birthday. We were welcomed warmly and promptly shown to our table. Our waitress Olivia promptly came, introduced herself and said Happy Birthday as she added glitter to our table. From there we were awarded with smiles, complimentary champagne and caviar platter. Olivia very eloquently and efficiently presented the meat platter. it was hard to decide which cut looked more appetizing. We ordered our meal and thoroughly enjoyed it. I had the red snapper and hubby had filet mignon. the portions were generous, and the taste was fresh and savory. then came dessert ... we ordered the carrot cake was HUGE (and we ordered the 1/2 portion). Dinner at Nick & Sam's is an experience - from the warm welcome to Olivia's attentiveness to the staff stopping by to say Happy Birthday. Nick & Sam's is more than a menu ... it's an adventure!! we can't wait to come back!!

I cannot even begin to express how amazing this place it. There was not a single item on the menu that was bad and trust me we tried them all. I'm not sure if this was because it was our first time but we got complimentary caviar and champagne. They also had a massive cake and cotton candy made for my wife's birthday. Look at the pictures to see the food quality. It was pricey but the portions are massive and you will be coming home with extras.

Dining at Nick & Sam’s was an absolutely phenomenal experience! The service was stellar—attentive, professional, and warm from start to finish. The food was nothing short of exquisite, with every dish beautifully presented and bursting with flavor. The atmosphere struck the perfect balance of upscale elegance without feeling stuffy, and the noise level was just right for easy, relaxed conversation. I’m glad we chose to dine here during our weekend get away!

This restaurant was really good! It can be really crowded, but they show you the different steak cuts at the table and let you choose which state that you want. Also they do these really cool birthday celebrations where they have a cotton candy that is lit up with sparklers and they bring it to the table for you. Also they had a really great wine selection and had really bottles that were on display when you first walk in. Would definitely go back

We celebrated our wedding anniversary at Nick & Sam’s, and it was nothing short of extraordinary. The food was phenomenal, but what truly elevated the experience was the hospitality—especially from our waiter, Jared. Jared was exceptional. He was attentive without being overbearing, knowledgeable about the menu, and genuinely invested in making our evening special. His timing, warmth, and professionalism made us feel like honored guests. Both managers also stopped by to personally wish us well, adding a thoughtful touch that made the night even more memorable. It was one of the best anniversary dinners we’ve ever had at a restaurant. Nick & Sam’s knows how to make a celebration feel truly special.

So this place is really over-the-top. It’s great for celebrations. It’s a little noisy in there, but it’s because everyone is having so much fun with all their unusual creations. They bring the meat to the table for you to look at before you order your steak. They have the largest fancy cakes and cotton candy I’ve ever seen and they use a lot of dry ice for drama!!! Plus everything tastes pretty good. Definitely would go again!! But bring your wallet $$$$$$$$!

Such a lovely steakhouse with a great vibe. The steaks were cooked perfectly—juicy, flavorful, and just how we ordered. The staff was super friendly and knew the menu well, which made the experience even better. The decor is upscale and modern, though the tables are a bit too close for comfort. It felt a little cramped at times. Tip: Definitely add the mushroom or caramelized onion toppers to your steak, they’re amazing! Also, don’t skip dessert, the layered birthday cake was incredibly soft and delicious.

Review of Nick & Sam’s Steakhouse – A Birthday to Remember Celebrating my birthday at Nick & Sam’s Steakhouse was, without a doubt, one of the best dining experiences I’ve ever had. From the moment we arrived, the atmosphere was upscale yet welcoming — the perfect setting for a special evening with family. But what truly made the night unforgettable was our waiter, whose name I think was either James or Jeff. He mentioned he had recently moved from Seattle, and let me tell you — wherever he came from, they lost a star. This guy was on point the entire night. He wasn’t just providing service — he was curating an experience. He asked about what kind of meal I wanted and somehow pulled together the perfect combination of starters, sides, and a steak that was cooked to absolute perfection. Every dish he recommended hit the mark. He made us feel like VIPs, but in a warm and sincere way. My family was just as impressed. He took care of the entire table effortlessly, anticipated what we needed before we even asked, and added personal touches throughout the meal that really made the celebration feel elevated. From wine pairings to dessert, everything was thoughtfully handled. Nick & Sam’s already has a reputation for excellence — and they absolutely live up to it. The food, ambiance, and service all exceeded expectations. But it was our waiter’s attention to detail and genuine hospitality that turned a great dinner into a truly memorable birthday night. If you’re looking to celebrate something special or just want an exceptional night out, this place is worth every penny. And if you happen to get James or Jeff from Seattle — you’re in for a treat.